Bitcoin or Gold: Which Is Better? 2026 Returns and Risk Data

Last updated November 11, 2026
Table of Contents

Bitcoin or gold, which is better? Neither wins for every purpose. Over the five years to 9 November 2026, gold rose 125.3% in US dollars and bitcoin 11.0%, and bitcoin swung almost three times as hard. Over ten years bitcoin is far ahead, and over three years the two are close. The start date decides the winner. This guide shows the measured returns, the worst falls and what the labels promise, so you can judge what each could do to your money on the way.

TL;DR: Over five years to 9 November 2026, gold returned +125.3% and bitcoin +11.0%. Bitcoin’s volatility was 51.6% against gold’s 18.1%, and its worst fall was -76.5% against -27.6%. Over ten years bitcoin returned +10,288.6%. Gold was not calm in 2026 either: it fell 27.6% from its January record. Neither is a guaranteed safe haven, so size any position from the worst fall you can sit through.

All figures below are our own calculations of price returns in US dollars, to 9 November 2026, the last complete day of data. Gold uses the LBMA Gold Price PM, the London benchmark set at 15:00, read through the World Gold Council. Bitcoin uses Bitstamp prices at the same 15:00 London moment. The figures leave out fees, spreads, storage and tax. Past returns do not predict future ones.

The answer depends on the job you give the money

Gold has been the steadier of the two. Bitcoin has been the bigger mover, in both directions. If you need money that will not halve before you spend it, gold fits better: its worst fall in ten years was 27.6%. If you can hold through a fall of three quarters and wait years for a recovery, bitcoin has paid far more since 2016, though the result swings with the start date.

In 2026 gold fell hard after its January record, and the volatility gap between the two narrowed. So “gold is safe, bitcoin is risky” is too simple: both can lose a large share of their value within a year.

What USD 1,000 did over three, five and ten years

Volatility is how widely a price swings in a typical year, shown as a yearly percentage. The worst fall, or maximum drawdown, is the largest drop from a peak to a later low inside the window.

Comparison card of US dollar price returns to 9 November 2026: gold +110.3%, +125.3% and +221.3% over 3, 5 and 10 years, bitcoin +97.4%, +11.0% and +10,288.6%

Window to 9 Nov 2026 Gold return Bitcoin return Gold volatility Bitcoin volatility Gold worst fall Bitcoin worst fall
1 year +3.1% -25.7% 27.3% 41.0% -27.6% -44.5%
3 years +110.3% +97.4% 20.5% 46.4% -27.6% -53.5%
5 years +125.3% +11.0% 18.1% 51.6% -27.6% -76.5%
10 years +221.3% +10,288.6% 16.2% 66.0% -27.6% -82.6%

Say you had put USD 1,000 into each on 9 November 2021. This is a hypothetical, past, price-only example. The gold stake would be worth about USD 2,253, a gain of 17.6% a year. The bitcoin stake would be worth about USD 1,110, or 2.1% a year.

Move the start back five years and the picture flips. From 9 November 2016, gold made 12.4% a year and bitcoin 59.1% a year. Move it forward to 2023 and they finish close: +110.3% for gold, +97.4% for bitcoin.

Rolling windows show how often each side won. Across 2,261 overlapping 12-month windows since October 2016, gold beat bitcoin in 38% of them. Bitcoin lost money in 33% of the windows and gold in 23%. The worst 12-month stretch for gold was -15.7%, from August 2020 to August 2021. For bitcoin it was -80.9%, from December 2017 to December 2018.

A mix changes less than people expect. A hypothetical 90% gold and 10% bitcoin split, rebalanced every 9 November from 2021, ends at about USD 2,303. Its volatility is 17.9% and its worst fall -26.5%, close to gold alone. That is one past path, not a recommended weight.

Volatility and the worst falls, measured

Over five years, bitcoin’s volatility of 51.6% is about 2.8 times gold’s 18.1%. Its worst fall, -76.5%, ran from a peak on 10 November 2021 to a low on 22 November 2022. It got back to that peak on 5 March 2024, about 2.3 years after the top. Over ten years the worst was -82.6%, from 18 December 2017 to 14 December 2018, with recovery on 24 November 2020.

Facts card for the five years to 9 November 2026: volatility 18.1% for gold and 51.6% for bitcoin, worst fall from a peak -27.6% for gold and -76.5% for bitcoin

Gold’s worst fall in both windows is happening now. The LBMA price set a record of 5,405.00 on 29 January 2026. The World Gold Council’s Q1 2026 report says “The price hit a historical high of US$5,405/oz in January, followed by a notable correction.” By 30 October 2026 the price was down to 3,913.25, a fall of 27.6%. On 9 November it was still 23.8% below the record.

On 9 November bitcoin was 40.2% under its 15:00 London peak of 6 October 2025. CoinGecko dates its all-time high to the same day.

The gap between the two has narrowed. Over ten years bitcoin was 4.1 times as volatile as gold (66.0% against 16.2%). Over the last twelve months it was only 1.5 times (41.0% against 27.3%). Gold’s volatility in 2026 so far is 29%, its highest in any calendar year since 2008.

Year by year, the leader keeps changing

Each year starts from the last gold fixing of the year before. For 2026, bitcoin starts from the 30 December 2025 fixing, because the LBMA holds no afternoon auction on 31 December.

Year Gold return Bitcoin return Gold volatility Bitcoin volatility
2021 -4.3% +68.0% 15% 86%
2022 +0.4% -64.9% 15% 63%
2023 +14.6% +156.7% 13% 49%
2024 +25.5% +114.8% 14% 55%
2025 +67.4% -3.1% 18% 43%
2026 to 9 Nov -5.7% -15.7% 29% 40%

Bitcoin beat gold in three of the six years, each time by a wide margin. Gold led in the other three, including 2022, when bitcoin fell 64.9%. Bitcoin moved further in five of the six years. In 2025 gold had its best year in this table while bitcoin slipped. In 2026 both are down.

What the safe haven and digital gold labels promise

A safe haven is an asset that holds or gains value when other markets crash. The classic study, by Baur and Lucey (Financial Review, 2010), found that “gold is a hedge against stocks on average and a safe haven in extreme stock market conditions.” It added that “the safe haven property is short-lived.” Our page on gold and stocks correlation covers that evidence.

2026 tested the label. The BIS (Quarterly Review, March 2026) wrote that gold and silver “surged early in 2026, reflecting a unique mix of investors’ quest for safe havens and speculative interest”. It then described precious metals as “trading more like risk assets than safe havens”. In September it added: “Gold extended its decline from early-year peaks and recovered ground only when fiscal woes gained prominence.” Our guide to risk assets explains why such assets fall together.

Other research links gold to world events. A BIS working paper from October 2026 finds that rising geopolitical risk lifts gold returns, more so when financial conditions are loose.

Correlation measures whether two prices move together: +1 means always together, 0 means no link. Weekly bitcoin and gold returns had a correlation of 0.18 over five years. By calendar year it was 0.00 in 2024 and 0.32 in 2026. So the two are not opposites, and they moved together more often this year.

“Digital gold” rests on supply. The Bitcoin Wiki states that “the number of bitcoins in existence will not exceed slightly less than 21 million”. Scarcity limits supply. It does not set demand, and the -76.5% fall happened with the same fixed supply.

Size, supply and who is buying each

Gold is far larger. The World Gold Council puts all gold above ground at 224,200 tonnes, worth US$30.0tn at the end of Q3 2026 (How much gold). Block data on mempool.space puts about 20.11 million bitcoin in issue on 11 November 2026, by our count from the block height. At the 9 November price that is about US$1.5tn, so gold is roughly 20 times larger.

New supply is small for both. Since block 840,000 on 20 April 2024, each block adds 3.125 bitcoin. That works out at about 164,250 coins a year, or 0.82% of supply, and the reward halves every 210,000 blocks. Our bitcoin halving entry explains the schedule. Gold mines produced 884.7 tonnes in Q1 2026, up 2% on a year earlier, per the WGC.

Buyers differ most. In its Q3 2026 release the WGC says central banks “added a net 321t to reserves in Q3, up 42% year-on-year”. Gold ETFs added 211 tonnes, taking holdings to a record 4,256 tonnes. The ECB reports that gold’s share of official reserves reached 27% at the end of 2025, and that “this development largely reflects valuation effects”. None of the sources we read reports central bank buying of bitcoin.

Protection and tax when you own or trade in the UK

The FCA’s InvestSmart page tells crypto buyers: “you should be prepared to lose all the money you have invested”. It also says “Crypto prices can move suddenly with no warning”, and that crypto investors are “unlikely to have access to” FSCS or Financial Ombudsman protection. For firms, the FCA notes it lifted “the ban on retail access to certain cETNs” (cETN page), which are crypto exchange-traded notes.

Retail results back the warning. BIS Bulletin No 69 (2023) found that “a majority of crypto app users in nearly all economies made losses on their bitcoin holdings”.

Tax is the other cost of holding. HMRC guidance treats selling, exchanging, spending or giving away crypto as a disposal for Capital Gains Tax, and asks you to keep your own records.

Trading is a different route from owning. A CFD (contract for difference) lets you trade the price change without owning the asset. On Volity, gold trades as a CFD on XAU/USD and XAU/EUR, long or short, so there is no metal to store or insure. Our page on what XAU means explains the code. For holding gold against cash, compare gold vs a savings account, and for the wider case read is gold a good investment.

Trading bitcoin and gold on Volity

On Volity, crypto and a growing range of markets, gold and silver among them, trade 24/7. Forex trades 24/5. Gold and crypto CFDs sit in the same account as forex, indices and commodities. The gold trading platform page shows how gold works there.

On Volity, metals trade with leverage up to 1:500.

Crypto CFDs trade with leverage up to 1:50.

Leverage magnifies losses as much as gains. Margin, the deposit a trade ties up, is the position size divided by the leverage. At 1:50, margin is 2% of the position, so a 2% move against you equals the whole margin. At 1:500, margin is 0.2%, and a 0.2% move does the same.

  1. Decide the job first: a long hold or a short trade with a set exit.
  2. Open the free demo, available on every account tier, and watch both markets over a full week, weekend included.
  3. Note how far each moves in a day before you choose a position size.
  4. Size from your stop-loss, the price at which you exit, and not from the leverage on offer.
  5. Set a target too, and check the trade with the risk-reward ratio.
  6. Check costs before going live. The Markets account is commission-free, spreads are dynamic, and positions held overnight pay or receive a financing amount. The full schedule is on the charges and fees page, and order handling is in the execution policy.

Try the free demo

A Volity Markets account starts from $1, with funding from 10 EUR.

Open your Volity account

Before you choose either asset, write down the worst fall you could sit through without selling. Over the last five years, gold asked holders to sit through -27.6% and bitcoin -76.5%.

Fact check: Returns, volatility, drawdowns and correlations are our own calculations from the LBMA Gold Price PM via the World Gold Council and from Bitstamp BTC/USD at 15:00 London, to 9 November 2026; no price series is reproduced. Gold market data from the World Gold Council (Q1 and Q3 2026). Safe-haven wording from the BIS Quarterly Reviews of March and September 2026; reserves from the ECB (June 2026); UK guidance from the FCA and HMRC. Checked 11 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, bitcoin or gold?

Neither is better for every purpose. Over five years to 9 November 2026, gold returned +125.3% and bitcoin +11.0%. Over ten years bitcoin returned +10,288.6%. Gold has been steadier, bitcoin the bigger mover both ways.

Is bitcoin more volatile than gold?

Yes. Over five years, bitcoin’s volatility was 51.6% against 18.1% for gold. The gap narrowed in 2026: over the last twelve months it was 41.0% against 27.3%, about 1.5 times.

Is gold still a safe haven after 2026?

Gold fell 27.6% from its January 2026 record to its 30 October low. The BIS described precious metals in early 2026 as “trading more like risk assets than safe havens”. Baur and Lucey (2010) found the safe-haven effect short-lived.

Do bitcoin and gold move together?

Loosely. Their weekly correlation was 0.18 over five years, where 1 means always together. In 2024 it was 0.00, and in 2026 it rose to 0.32, so they moved together more often this year.

Can bitcoin replace gold?

The data does not show it. Gold above ground was worth US$30.0tn at the end of Q3 2026, against about US$1.5tn for bitcoin. Central banks added a net 321 tonnes of gold in Q3 2026, per the WGC.

How is bitcoin taxed in the UK?

HMRC treats selling, exchanging, spending or giving away crypto as a disposal for Capital Gains Tax. You need to keep your own records of each transaction. Check the GOV.UK guidance for your own case.

Start Your Days Smarter!