Buy the Dip: What 74 S&P 500 Falls Since 1950 Show

Last updated November 11, 2026
Table of Contents

Buy the dip means buying a share or an index after it has fallen from a recent high, in the hope that it recovers. Does it work? Since 1950, the S&P 500 was higher 12 months after a first close 5% below its high in 70% of 71 cases, but in 54% it closed at least 5% lower again within that year. This guide shows the record for the S&P 500, FTSE 100 and DAX, what waiting in cash cost, and how to write a dip rule you can test on a demo.

TL;DR: A dip needs a written rule, such as the first close 5% or 10% below the highest close. On S&P 500 prices since 1950, 70% of 5% dips and 69% of 10% dips were higher a year later, yet more than half fell at least another 5% within that year. Waiting in cash for a 10% dip beat buying at once in only 43% of monthly start dates. Buying in steps softened deep falls and cost return in shallow ones. No rule tells you which kind of dip you are in.

How we measured: we recomputed every figure from Yahoo Finance daily closes for the S&P 500 (from 1950), the FTSE 100 (from 1984) and the DAX (from 1987), to 6 November 2026. The S&P 500 and FTSE 100 series are price indices, without dividends. The DAX series is a total-return index: STOXX notes that it “also takes dividends into account”, so DAX figures are labelled. As a cross-check, the feed’s yearly S&P 500 price return was below the total return in Damodaran’s table in all 75 years from 1951 to 2025, by a median 3.12 points, about the dividend yield. One bad close in the feed (17 April 1961) was corrected from a second source. This is history, not a forecast.

What buy the dip means, and what counts as a dip

The weak point of the idea is the word dip. A 2% fall in a day and 30% in a year can both be called one. Without a written rule, you decide in the moment, when fear and hope are strongest.

The rule here uses closing prices. The peak is the highest close so far. The drawdown is how far today’s close sits below that peak. A 5% dip starts on the first close at least 5% below the peak, and a 10% dip on the first close 10% below. Each dip counts once, until a new closing high.

A threshold matters because being below a high is normal. Since 1950 the S&P 500 spent 51.0% of trading days at least 5% below its closing high. The FTSE 100 spent 62.0% of days there and the DAX 65.2% (dividends included). Being in a dip barely changed the odds. From all S&P 500 days, the index was higher 12 months later 75% of the time, with a median gain of 10.6%. From days at least 5% below the high, it was 77% and 11.9%. These windows overlap, so read them as a shape, not as separate tests.

How often a dip recovered after 1, 3 and 12 months

The S&P 500 had 74 dips of 5% since 1950, about one a year, and 26 dips of 10%, about one every three years. After a 5% dip, the index was higher one month later in 75% of cases, three months later in 75% and 12 months later in 70%. After a 10% dip the figures were 65%, 65% and 69%. The median, the middle result when all cases are lined up, was a 12-month gain of 9.4% after a 5% dip and 13.5% after a 10% dip.

Bar chart card of S&P 500 closes since 1950: after a 5% dip 70% were higher a year later and 54% fell 5% more within it; after a 10% dip, 69% and 65%

One 5% dip in nine was followed by a 12-month change of minus 10% or worse. The worst was a 36.9% loss, from the November 2007 signal.

Index and dip Dips Higher after 12 months Old high regained within 12 months Fell 10% more within 12 months
S&P 500, 5% (price) 74 70% 83% 32%
S&P 500, 10% (price) 26 69% 65% 46%
FTSE 100, 5% (price) 30 72% 76% 34%
FTSE 100, 10% (price) 15 87% 60% 27%
DAX, 5% (dividends included) 38 60% 77% 46%
DAX, 10% (dividends included) 16 60% 47% 53%

The pattern holds in all three markets: most dips were higher a year later, and a large minority first fell much further. Dips also tend to start from high prices. The Bank of England’s Financial Stability Report of July 2026 said that “risky asset prices have reached high levels.” That describes the setting, not the timing of any fall.

The falling knife: how far dips kept falling

A falling knife is a price that keeps dropping after you buy. In the data it is common. After a 5% dip, the S&P 500 closed at least 5% below the trigger close within 12 months in 54% of cases, and at least 10% below in 32%. After a 10% dip, it went a further 5% lower in 65% of cases and a further 10% lower in 46%. The median time from the trigger to the low was 12 days for a 5% dip and 56 days for a 10% dip.

The first days of a fall do not tell you which kind you are in. In 2020 the S&P 500 fell 33.9% in 23 trading days, from 3,386.15 on 19 February to 2,237.40 on 23 March. It first closed above the old high again on 18 August. In 2022 the 10% signal came on 22 February, at 4,304.76. The low close of 3,577.03 on 12 October was 16.9% lower, and the old high took 696 calendar days to return. After the 10% signals of 2000 and 2007, the index fell a further 42.7% and 51.9%, and needed 2,602 and 1,949 days to regain its high.

Fast recoveries have their own causes. From 6,144.15 on 19 February 2025, the S&P 500 fell 18.9% to a close of 4,982.77 on 8 April. The BIS Quarterly Review of September 2025 wrote that it “recovered all early-April losses by the end of the same month and surpassed its pre-stress peak in just under 20 weeks”. It linked the rebound through mid-May mainly to “backtracking from the initial tariff shock”. A BIS working paper estimated that “more than 60% of the equity market recovery can be traced to tariff-related shocks”. A dip buyer in early April could not have known a policy reversal was coming.

In a rush to sell, even assets seen as safe can fall with shares. In a 2022 speech on the March 2020 dash for cash, Jon Cunliffe of the Bank of England said: “The gold price fell by 12%.” See why risk assets tend to move together.

What waiting in cash for a dip has cost

Some investors hold cash, often called dry powder, and wait for a fall. On the S&P 500, from the first trading day of each month from 1950 to 2016, 803 start dates in all, the waiter held cash until the index closed 10% below its highest close since the start, or bought anyway after 12 months. We compared the value ten years later with buying on day one.

A 10% dip came within 12 months in 54% of start dates. Yet the waiter paid more than the day-one price in 57% of them, because prices often rose first. Waiting won in 43% of starts. The median ten-year result was 2.20 times the money for buying at once and 2.05 times for waiting, a median shortfall of 3.3%.

Some details cut the other way. Cash earned 0% in the test, which is biased against the waiter. With a 5% trigger, a dip came within a year in 94% of starts and waiting won 56% of the time, with a median gain of 0.8%. On the FTSE 100, waiting for 10% won 47% of the time, and on the DAX (dividends included) 50%.

Vanguard’s 2023 study compared a lump sum with spreading the money out. It found that “Lump-sum investment strategies beat common cost averaging investment strategies two-thirds of the time, according to historical and simulated market data.” That tests phased buying, not waiting for a dip, yet it points the same way. If you add money each month instead, see our guide to regular investing.

A staged entry, worked through with real closes

A staged entry buys in steps as the fall deepens. We tested it on every S&P 500 5% dip with a full year of data: one third at 5% below the high, one at 10% and one at 15%, with unused parts left in cash at 0%. Staging beat buying everything at the first trigger in 33 of 71 episodes, or 46%. Its median 12-month result was a gain of 4.0%, against 9.4% for buying at once.

Comparison card of a hypothetical 3,000 on real S&P 500 closes: buying at once against a staged entry after 12 months, in 2022, February 2020, September 2020 and 2007

The four cases below are hypothetical. They use real S&P 500 closes, price only, with no costs: 3,000 split into three parts of 1,000, valued 12 months after the first buy.

Start of the fall Buys at closes of All at once Staged
2022, peak 4,796.56 4,532.76; 4,304.76; 3,991.24 2,580 (-14.0%) 2,743 (-8.6%)
February 2020, peak 3,386.15 3,128.21; 2,978.76; 2,746.56 3,672 (+22.4%) 3,904 (+30.1%)
September 2020, peak 3,580.84 3,331.84 only 4,064 (+35.5%) 3,355 (+11.8%)
October 2007 peak 1,475.62; 1,407.22; 1,325.19 1,893 (-36.9%) 1,995 (-33.5%)

Staging softened the deep falls. In 2022 it lost 8.6% instead of 14.0%, while the index went on to a close of 3,577.03, 25.4% below the peak. In September 2020 the index never reached 10% below its high, so two thirds of the money sat in cash and staging made 11.8% against 35.5%. Staging reduces regret. It does not remove risk.

Write your dip rule before the market falls

None of these numbers signals that a dip has ended. What you control is the plan, so write it while prices are calm.

  1. Pick the trigger: the market and the threshold, such as the first close 5% or 10% below the highest close.
  2. Size the position for a deeper fall. After a 10% dip, the S&P 500 fell at least 10% further within a year in 46% of cases. A 20% drawdown needs a 25% gain to get back to even, and a 50% drawdown needs 100%.
  3. Decide the add-on rule: the levels for any later buys and what happens to unused cash.
  4. Set a time limit. If no dip comes within, say, 12 months, decide now whether you buy anyway or switch to regular investing.
  5. Choose the order type. A limit order buys only at your price or better, but may not fill if the market turns first. In a fast market, a market order can fill at a worse price, which is called slippage.
  6. Write what would make you stop. Set a loss limit and a target before you enter; the risk-reward ratio guide shows how. For a single company, index history says nothing about its results, so the reason for the fall matters.
  7. Rehearse on a demo and log each trigger, each fill and the result after 1, 3 and 12 months.

Try the free demo

Buying dips on Volity with shares or CFDs

On Volity you can trade real shares, fractional shares, crypto and CFDs in one account. A fractional share is part of one share, which suits a staged plan with small amounts. A CFD, or contract for difference, tracks a price without you owning the asset, so you can go long, or go short if you expect a fall.

Stock CFDs trade with leverage up to 1:20. Leverage lets a small deposit control a larger position, so it magnifies losses as well as gains.

Regulators limit leverage for retail clients in some places. In the UK, the FCA made permanent a rule that firms selling CFDs to retail clients must “Limit leverage to between 30:1 and 2:1” (FCA, 2019).

A dip trade can take months to work. CFD positions held past 22:00 GMT may pay or receive an overnight amount, based on the interest-rate difference, or the leverage cost for non-forex CFDs. The rate for each instrument is shown on the platform, and the full schedule is on the Volity charges and fees page. The Markets account is commission-free.

The free demo is available on every Volity account tier. Set up your written rule there and log what happens before you use real money. A Volity Markets account starts from $1, with funding from 10 EUR.

Open your account

A written rule cannot change these odds. It only makes sure you act on them on purpose.

Fact check: Index figures are our own recomputation from Yahoo Finance daily closes to 6 November 2026 (S&P 500 from 1950, FTSE 100 from 1984, DAX from 1987), accessed 11 November 2026. S&P 500 and FTSE 100 are price indices; the DAX includes dividends (STOXX). Cross-check: Damodaran, NYU Stern (January 2026). Other sources: BIS Quarterly Review September 2025, BIS Working Paper 1282, Bank of England Financial Stability Report July 2026, Vanguard (February 2023), FCA (2019). Volity details checked 11 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What does buy the dip mean?

It means buying a share or an index after it has fallen from a recent high, expecting a recovery. A useful version has a written trigger, such as the first close 5% or 10% below the highest close.

How much of a fall counts as a dip?

There is no official figure. This article uses 5% and 10% below the highest close. On S&P 500 prices since 1950, that gave 74 dips of 5% and 26 of 10%.

Is it better to buy the dip or invest regularly?

The record leans towards investing sooner. In our S&P 500 test, waiting in cash for a 10% dip beat buying at once in 43% of start dates. Vanguard found that lump sums beat cost averaging two-thirds of the time.

How do I avoid catching a falling knife?

You cannot rule it out. After a 10% dip, the S&P 500 fell at least 10% further within a year in 46% of cases. Keep each position small enough that a further fall is affordable.

What is dry powder?

Dry powder is cash held back to buy after a fall. In our S&P 500 test the waiter paid more than the day-one price in 57% of start dates, because prices often rose before the dip came.

How long does a dip take to recover?

On the S&P 500 since 1950, the median time to regain the old high was 62 days after a 5% dip and 298 days after a 10% dip. The longest took 2,717 days, more than seven years.

Start Your Days Smarter!